• Home
  • News
    Overzealous customs officer in soup for slapping Okowa’s aide

    Overzealous customs officer in soup for slapping Okowa’s aide

    admin 10 May 2022
    • Fire at SCOAN old site: NO cause for alarm, says mgt

      Albert Uba 28 Apr 2022
    • Chrisland: 15 yr-old girl at center of viral sex video break silence, apologizes

      Chrisland: 15 yr-old girl at center of viral sex video break silence, apologizes

      Albert Uba 26 Apr 2022
    • Navy records tremendous success in fight against crude oil theft in Nigeria

      Navy records tremendous success in fight against crude oil theft in Nigeria

      Albert Uba 25 Apr 2022
    • Exercise Obagame Express2022: 27 Nigerians, 7 Beniniose arrested on board wanted vessels

      Exercise Obagame Express2022: 27 Nigerians, 7 Beniniose arrested on board wanted vessels

      Albert Uba 23 Mar 2022
    • State of the nation: DSS alerts on violence plot in North-central Nigeria, warns plotters

      State of the nation: DSS alerts on violence plot in North-central Nigeria, warns plotters

      admin 20 Mar 2022
    • Igboho barred from entering Nigeria until…

      Igboho barred from entering Nigeria until…

      Albert Uba 09 Mar 2022
    • NIS: Interior Minister, Ag CG, others accused of double standard in appointment of CG

      NIS: Interior Minister, Ag CG, others accused of double standard in appointment of CG

      Albert Uba 08 Mar 2022
    • How Lagos NSCDC bust attempt to ferry 117 25ltr kegs of fuel to Benin Republic

      How Lagos NSCDC bust attempt to ferry 117 25ltr kegs of fuel to Benin Republic

      Albert Uba 06 Mar 2022
  • Features
  • Opinion
    Why China Will Reclaim Siberia (OPINION)

    Why China Will Reclaim Siberia (OPINION)

    Albert Uba 12 Feb 2022
    China, Russia Have Central Asia Problem

    China, Russia Have Central Asia Problem

    Albert Uba 19 Jan 2022
    Oluwo carpets Buhari on anti- corruption crusade, says govt playing the ostrich

    Oluwo carpets Buhari on anti- corruption crusade, says govt playing the ostrich

    admin 26 Nov 2021
    Of SCOAN and Misadventure of ungrateful disciples (OPINION)

    Of SCOAN and Misadventure of ungrateful disciples (OPINION)

    Albert Uba 25 Oct 2021
  • Editorial
  • Special Focus
    Nigerian ICT wizard, Aliyu dares facebok, twitter others with ShapClik one-in-all App

    Nigerian ICT wizard, Aliyu dares facebok, twitter others with ShapClik one-in-all App

    Albert Uba 03 Feb 2022
    Nigeria needs to be safe, secure for thriving socio-economic activities-DR. OBI

    Nigeria needs to be safe, secure for thriving socio-economic activities-DR. OBI

    Albert Uba 08 Oct 2021
    DCP AKINBAYO: Breaking uncommon frontiers in developmental policing in Nigeria

    DCP AKINBAYO: Breaking uncommon frontiers in developmental policing in Nigeria

    Albert Uba 18 Aug 2021
    Again, rights group reiterates calls for unconditional release of condemned Rev. King

    Again, rights group reiterates calls for unconditional release of condemned Rev. King

    Albert Uba 29 May 2021
  • Elevation
  • Inside Court
  • NDLEA
  • Police
Home» Opinion»China, Russia Have Central Asia Problem
China, Russia Have Central Asia Problem

China, Russia Have Central Asia Problem

19 Jan 2022 Opinion Leave a comment 88 Views


OPINION

By Clara MARQUES

DURING the Kazakhstan’s recent unrest, Moscow and Beijing seemed to slip into their conventional roles in the region — the “gun” and the “wallet.” But that equilibrium won’t hold.

Russia’s decision last week to help the Kazakh government crush an uprising and China’s muted response have been taken as more evidence of a kind of geopolitical equilibrium in one of the region’s most vital to both. Moscow remains the primary security guarantor, the argument goes, while Beijing is content to exercise its influence through investment.

Not quite. Indeed, the aftermath of unrest in Kazakhstan could even surface buried tensions between the two giant frenemies over what happens in their shared backyard, against a changing backdrop that already threatens the idea of an informal condominium of interests.

The unprecedented move by the Russian-led Collective Security Treaty Organization to send troops in response to President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev’s appeal — something it did not do for Armenia during the Nagorno-Karabakh war in 2020, for example — certainly reinforces Russia’s role as regional protector, or at least, protector of friendly autocratic regimes. China, meanwhile, did keep a low profile. It was initially silent, then declared the demonstrations were an “internal affair.” Only later did it echo the questionable official narrative, declaring its opposition to “color revolutions” and its willingness to support the fight against the “three evil forces,” a phrase intended to describe extremism, secessionism and terrorism.

The division of labor narrative is useful. It’s allowed Beijing to pursue its interests behind a stance of non-interference. Russia, meanwhile, has been able to explain away the growing presence of a rival power on its southern border. The Eurasian Economic Union, Russia’s effort at integration, works alongside Beijing’s more expansive Belt-and-Road initiative. Although Central Asia matters to Moscow, no countries as integral to President Vladimir Putin’s sense of national identity as Ukraine or Belarus are involved.

Read Also >>INSECURITY: Nigeria in for worse situation as FETO members infiltrate country, reveals Turkish President Recep

But the distinction is far less neat than the “gun and wallet” aphorism or the past few days suggest, and the balance far less secure.

Take the “wallet.” While trade with China and Chinese investment into energy, mining and infrastructure over the past decade or so have grown at an impressive pace, Moscow’s economic ties to the region are strong. Russian firms still account for a chunk of foreign-owned business, and Russia is still a magnet for the region’s workers. Remittances account for close to a third and more than a quarter of gross domestic product for Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan, respectively.

More crucially for the future of this balance, though, there’s the “gun.” China has without question used pipelines and hydrocarbon rents as the primary glue for its relationships in the region. Yet China also has significant military aspirations and security fears, especially in a neighborhood that is seen a necessary buffer between Afghanistan and China’s western territories, home to non-Han minorities who have felt the full force of China’s repressive machinery.

Under an emboldened President Xi Jinping, China has loosened its interpretation of non-interference and moved past Deng Xiaoping’s recommendation that China should hide its strength, bide its time and “never claim leadership.” China has demanded a greater role on the geopolitical stage and expanded its security footprint abroad, including in Central Asia. That’s through private security actors protecting Chinese assets — economic interests are rarely isolated — but also military aid, exercises and, in Tajikistan, troops monitoring a choke point just beyond China’s frontier. Last year, Tajikistan accepted a Chinese proposal to finance a police base on the Tajik-Afghan border.

China has increased its regional security cooperation with the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, which includes Russia, but also, since 2016, with the Quadrilateral Cooperation and Coordination Mechanism, a counterterrorism forum that counts Afghanistan, Pakistan and Tajikistan. Beijing’s concerns have only increased since the U.S. departure from Afghanistan. None of that will comfort Russia.

Moreover, Kazakhstan’s troubles may prompt Beijing to reassess its vulnerability, given the importance of this vast neighbor which is also an important supplier of uranium, oil, gas and copper — it’s no accident that China chose Kazakhstan to launch its flagship Belt and Road in 2013.

As Temur Umarov at Carnegie Moscow Center pointed out to me, China has limited ability to interfere in Kazakh domestic politics. In that domain, for all the ties between China and the elites (with whom it remains more popular than with a more distrusting general population), Moscow has the upper hand. Putin still has more in common with local bigwigs than Xi does, giving him the confidence to step in and pick sides. China could only wait and see.

Read Also >>.How skewed protest against xenophobic attacks on Nigerians in China landed ‘Jehovah Sharp Sharp’ G.O. in Police cell, court

But it’s less clear what could happen if China’s interests and substantial investments were threatened. Tokayev, who was handpicked by Kazakhstan’s long-time leader Nursultan Nazarbayev, is now changing the elite guard after ousting his former protector. And as Alexander Cooley, a Barnard College political scientist and Central Asia-watcher, told me, the detention last week of Karim Massimov on state treason charges will have rattled Beijing. A former prime minister who was until recently head of the National Security Committee, Massimov is a Nazarbayev loyalist, but he is of Uyghur heritage, speaks Mandarin Chinese and was seen as the uppermost representative of the China lobby.

None of this suggests conflict in the region or even the Great Game scramble some analysts describe. China and Russia are still autocratic regimes with similar interests, not least in preserving stability, and the timely exit of Russian-led troops from Kazakhstan will reassure. Countries like Kazakhstan will continue to aim for a diplomatic balance. But Russia’s economic capacity to prop up regimes is not increasing. And with changes in the wind, China may no longer wish to remain sitting on the political and security sidelines.

Clara Ferreira Marques is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering commodities, environmental,social and governance issues.


Abuja Central Africa China Russia 2022-01-19
Tags Abuja Central Africa China Russia
Facebook Twitter Stumble linkedin Pinterest More
Previous Article :

KEREN: You’re a cheap blackmailer, School Magnt accuses Lemmy Ughegbe

Next Article :

Nigeria Interpol in landmark achievement, cracks syndicate of high profile cyber-criminals, arrests 12

Related Articles

Why China Will Reclaim Siberia (OPINION)

Why China Will Reclaim Siberia (OPINION)

Albert Uba 12 Feb 2022
Oluwo carpets Buhari on anti- corruption crusade, says govt playing the ostrich

Oluwo carpets Buhari on anti- corruption crusade, says govt playing the ostrich

admin 26 Nov 2021
Of SCOAN and Misadventure of ungrateful disciples (OPINION)

Of SCOAN and Misadventure of ungrateful disciples (OPINION)

Albert Uba 25 Oct 2021

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Viewed Posts

Lightfingered Accountant-General of Federation arrested for alleged 80bn fraud
EFCC

Lightfingered Accountant-General of Federation arrested for alleged 80bn fraud

17 May 2022
Police intensify fight against cultism in Lagos, sweep metropolis of 23 suspected cultists
Police

Police intensify fight against cultism in Lagos, sweep metropolis of 23 suspected cultists

07 Jun 2018
Synagogue church guest house in order before collapse —REPORT
News

Synagogue church guest house in order before collapse —REPORT

29 Mar 2019
CP Kayode ‘Sir K’ takes over C’River State Command…his intimidating profile
Police

CP Kayode ‘Sir K’ takes over C’River State Command…his intimidating profile

13 Jan 2021
New GOC 81 Div, Gen. Fejokwu visits Badagry monarch, Seme border Customs Comptroller, seeks peaceful co-existence
News

New GOC 81 Div, Gen. Fejokwu visits Badagry monarch, Seme border Customs Comptroller, seeks peaceful co-existence

28 Mar 2021

Website Traffic Counter

Flag Counter

Advertisement

Follow us

Newslater

Recent Posts

  • Lightfingered Accountant-General of Federation arrested for alleged 80bn fraud

    Lightfingered Accountant-General of Federation arrested for alleged 80bn fraud

    17 May 2022
  • How Police smoked out killers of owner of Famak British High School, Alhaji Sagir

    How Police smoked out killers of owner of Famak British High School, Alhaji Sagir

    16 May 2022
  • It’s fire for fire against street trading, illegal road blockers in Lagos-JEJELOYE

    It’s fire for fire against street trading, illegal road blockers in Lagos-JEJELOYE

    16 May 2022
  • Man fakes CSO to President Buhari, dupes victims of N200m

    Man fakes CSO to President Buhari, dupes victims of N200m

    16 May 2022
  • How we busted YahooYahoo Academy, arrest Owner, 16 ‘Trainees’ in Abuja-EFCC

    How we busted YahooYahoo Academy, arrest Owner, 16 ‘Trainees’ in Abuja-EFCC

    16 May 2022

Random Posts

Nigerian ICT wizard, Aliyu dares facebok, twitter others with ShapClik one-in-all App

Nigerian ICT wizard, Aliyu dares facebok, twitter others with ShapClik one-in-all App

Nigeria needs to be safe, secure for thriving socio-economic activities-DR. OBI

Nigeria needs to be safe, secure for thriving socio-economic activities-DR. OBI

DCP AKINBAYO: Breaking uncommon frontiers in developmental policing in Nigeria

DCP AKINBAYO: Breaking uncommon frontiers in developmental policing in Nigeria

Again, rights group reiterates calls for unconditional release of condemned Rev. King

Again, rights group reiterates calls for unconditional release of condemned Rev. King

Kidnappers of Imo Priest arrested, says Police

Kidnappers of Imo Priest arrested, says Police

Tags

Abdulrasheed Bawa Abuja ASABA Bawa Commissioner of Police CP Muhammed Ali CP Hakeem Odumosu EFCC IGP Alkali Usman Baba IGP Baba Kidnappers Lagos NDLEA Nigeria Police President Muhammadu Buhari
Copyright 2021, All Rights Reserved
Crimeworld Online magazine